Sunday, May 21, 2006

CHARTER OF DEMANDS

Following are the demands on which YFE is negotiating with the Union Govt. in Delhi

CHARTER OF DEMANDS

Deferral of the proposed hike in reservation in the central universities.

AND

An Expert Commission should be formed which would explore all the avenues of affirmative actions, review the efficiency of reservation1 as an affirmative action (considering both its benefits and drawbacks) and compare the efficiencies of the all possible affirmative actions. Thus it should come up with a fool proof and time bound strategy to uplift and empower the backward sections of our country without interfering with the overall development and well being of our Nation.

Implementation of the proposed extended reservation policy and any other new reservation policy only after the commission has submitted its report.

A white paper on the reservation policy.

1 We view reservations as a limited step to provide opportunities for the backward sections of our country to acquire education and employment.

AND

Places in the Government jobs that are remaining vacant due to lack of eligible candidates from the reserved category should be opened for other eligible candidates immediately.

AND

No action should be taken against the agitating students, interns and resident doctors in any form as regards to service break, termination, pay deduction, legal action etc.


AND

The Hon’ble Prime Minister should give a concrete statement on the issue.







WHAT DO WE MEAN BY EXPERT COMMISSION?

It should be a non-political non-parliamentary commission with members from judicial, social sciences, educational, scientific background. It should be formed in15 days and should submit its report within 1 year’s time.

WHAT WOULD BE ITS AIMS AND OBJECTIVE?

To come up with a fool proof and time bound* strategy to uplift and empower the backward sections of our country without interfering with the overall development and well being of our Nation.

WHAT SHOULD IT DO?

1) It would explore all the avenues of affirmative actions.
2) It would assess the efficiency of the existing reservations taking into consideration both its benefits and drawbacks. #
3) It would compare the efficiency of other means of affirmative actions with that of reservations.
4) It should find ways other than affirmative actions, which would help in changing the socio-economic system, which breeds exploitation and inequality.
5) It should come up with socio-economic criteria, which would exclude the affluent and those already having access to jobs and higher education. **
6) It should fix parameters to determine the degree of upliftment and empowerment of the backward sections so that when adequate degree is achieved the Government should stop the policy of affirmative actions.
7) It should always keep in mind that the affirmative actions whatever suggested by the Commission should never interfere with the overall development and well being of our Nation.

*We want that whatever affirmative actions would be followed should have an end-point defined. Parameters should be defined after which there would be no need for affirmative actions in the same lines as they are being given till date.

**Creamy layer should be applied for all.

#While assessing the policy the Commission should take in account the current data about the population distribution.

123 Comments:

At 4:35 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

THE CONSTITUTIONAL AMMENDMENT SHOULD BE SUBJECTED TO JUDICIAL SCRUTINY.

 
At 4:53 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

May I suggest , to call off the hunger strike for now.

 
At 5:16 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

The commission so appointed should use emperical and verifiable methods to compare the costs vs benefits of affirmative action and also compare alternate means of meeting social objectives as laid out by the country.

 
At 5:23 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

Please do not compromise on any of these in any condition. We are with you to extend full support!!

 
At 5:28 AM, Blogger 4india said...

At best, the politicians will agree to defer it untill seats are increased. It's highly unlikely that they would agree for a non-political-non-parliamentary body to be created because, their motives (which is already known to the youth), will be known to the public.(Of course, they can always reject the findings of this body, like they rejected the findings of Mukherjee commission regarding Netaji) So the agitation should have to be for quite a long time. It may not be advisable for some of our youth to continue hunger strike. Instead they should now conserve energy for a protracted war for the future of our country. The YFE should now take action to collect more support from public & for this fund is needed. Please open an account to which well-wishers can send money in form of DD. (will it be possible to collect fund on-line thru bank transfer or credit card ?)

 
At 5:34 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

My request to BJP(The only opposition party) to pay a setious attention and take up this issue on behalf of citizens of India. This is a really genuine issue and will lead to a bright future of the contry and then it will be a real 'Shining India'.

 
At 5:41 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

Please call off hunger strike and start more action in front of Parliament/Rastrapati Bhavan,etc. It will be a hard time but results will be sweet.

 
At 5:47 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

Many centuries people of England ruled on India by using method of Divide and Rule Now people of "Italy" coming to rule india by same method.

 
At 5:51 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

Your demands are reasonable. But particular importance is to be given for excluding the Creamy layer from all reservations.

 
At 5:54 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

Some Minister is reported to have said that excluding Creamy Layer would be difficult to implement. Is he trying to support the Creamy Layer? One should not vote for any Congress Candidate in the future.

 
At 5:54 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

All these your demands are quite logical and farward thinking. I could see no reason for anyone serious about upliftment of deprived casts to ignore these demands. Infact the demand for total review of reservation policy should come from SC/ST as majority of them are not at all benefitted from this in 59yrs.
Please do not compromise in any case otherwise we will feel diched and loose all hopes.

 
At 5:55 AM, Blogger Vimal Goyal said...

You can contribute to anti quota protests

Those protesting against the reservations should consider the following views :


Meet the vote politics on caste based reservations by the language the politicians understand i.e. votes. That is the most effective way.
Consider taking a pledge to vote against UPA entire life untill they roll back proposed increase in reservation, appoint non-political commission to examine issue whether reservations should be continued, in what form, on what basis and how long.
The pledge should be voluntary, honest and serious, non-political and a signed hard copy should be posted to Sonia Gandhi from all corners of the country with one copy to a central agency.
A central website should record the number of people taking pledge in an honest manner and should publish figures to media.
If number of people taking pledge not to vote for UPA is in thousands or lacs, the Govt. may not move but if it is in Crores, Govt. will have to move, otherwise they will be out of power in next elections.
The very fear of losing the votes of those against the caste based votes will discourage the politicians to play with merit for their attempt to garner vote bank of OBCs.
Poticians are dividing the people, so let us divide the politicians.
If they can not uplift the SC/ST by 68 years of reservation, they will take more than 100 years to prolong the reservations for OBC.
Develop proper central website, Mobilize students, rallies for mass pledge etc. rather than strike by Doctors alone.
The format for pledge should be breif and widely circulated through SMS, E-mails, Blog, rallies, posters etc.
Suggested draft is given below : "I pledge to vote against UPA my entire life untill the Govt. rolls back proposed increase in reservation and appoints non-political commission to examine the whole issue of reservations including its roll back over a period of time."
Vimal Goyal Delhi

 
At 5:56 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

I think we should add another thing to this, that the commission should made their findings public at the same time they submit it to the Govt.

 
At 5:57 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

Many centuries people of England ruled on India by using method of Divide and Rule Now people of "Italy" coming to rule india by same method.

 
At 6:00 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

The middle classes have always been trampled upon by the Congress Party. After increasing taxes, this party wants to take away the jobs of the middle classes.

 
At 6:01 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

Only the poor should be given the advantage of Reservations.

 
At 6:03 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

Only merit should prevail for admission to Educational Institutions offering Professional Courses. If students from Backward Communities make it in the merit list then please give them free education, free books and free hostel facilities.

 
At 6:04 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

create an account for money to be collected. and create a reserve of arms and ammunition. we wont let this country to go to dogs. If fools and eunuchs (politicians) are adamant to play to populist imagination, let us give them a real taste of blood.

 
At 6:04 AM, Anonymous raghav said...

There should be a time frame for ending all existing caste based reservations......may be reservations should be reduced by a few percentage points every year

 
At 6:08 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

Can Arjun Singh himself take such decision without the consent of Sonia . It is a game plan of Sonia to polarize voters in coming election of UP. Until we not shout slogan against Sonia congresi will not bother.

 
At 6:13 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

I think the politicians are still not hearing. They are either deaf or unconcerned.. I think its time to that the fight was taken to a point where it hurts them the most..

Keep the online petition on but also start the incremental build-up of pressure. I guess Three Weeks will be all that it takes to bring the UPA down and for Good.

 
At 6:54 AM, Anonymous Murali said...

If reservations are the way to go, then let us demand the following:

1) Candidates obtaining seats for education via reservations SHOULD compulsorily serve the institutes that serve the backward communities for atleast 5 years after their education.

2) They should also serve in rural places where backward communities need immediate help for at least 1 year.

If the logic for reservations is social upliftment, then I see the above should be implemented otherwise it does not serve the masses at all.

 
At 6:59 AM, Anonymous jayesh said...

if this charter of demands not being accepted by government then i guess this shuld better turn in to civil war against them.. i read on expressindia .com tat IMA mumbai agreed and are definately opposing reservation in higher education.. where r the rest of areas.. r they still unaware or still sleepin... guys u can give duration to this government to form committe but wat time limit have u given them to accept this charter of demands , definately it shuld not be more than 24 hrs...... go and give this to l k advani also and various other party leaders..
other day murli manohar joshi was speakin against the policy of divide and rule , sidhu has joined inn.. go to these pple with this charter of demand and ask them to raise their voice in parliament tomorrow. let the army pple come in, all respect to them , but i guess in noone can run the system as smooth as it can be by their own pple............ also make papers of all these demands including delhi chalo and charter of demands and publish in all possible news paper.. none of them are printin the demands of youth for equality. dont loose media and above all press support .. pple wont recognize us .. press has already shifted this event from front page news to page 3 and page 8 .. out of sight is ut of mind for general pple...... get the stuff in to handout papers and distribute them along morning newspaper...... get a general man walkin on street aware of our demands . guys noone can be softer than these. pple hardly know about these site
it is same pple comin and postin their thoughts here
appeal to mumbai IMA president to talk to other branches and help it out at higher level
i still beleive untill the entire health service is paralysed general man and these politician wont wake up .
get a press conference and speak ur demands in front of them. make it official. give time limit to government to take their descision also.. guys tell this government to act fast noww. prime minister took 8 days to open his mouth....... tats shame on him...

 
At 8:04 AM, Blogger 4india said...

NDTV-MODE poll says, 58% support reservation. Perhaps they conducted the poll in Tamilnadu. May be the survey was part financed by UPA govt.

 
At 8:11 AM, Blogger chinmay said...

hi...2day,21st may 06, we organised a silent protest rally against reservations here in Pune...there were around 500 students in it and many banners...AND students were from many fields like medical,engg.,law,CA,were in attendance.there were also working proffessionals from the IT field.

also,excellent charter of demands...we should also gradually demand total scrapping of exisying reservations.Lets turn this into a permanant fight against reservations.

 
At 8:17 AM, Blogger chinmay said...

i also fully agree with mr. vimal goyal of delhi.lets take the fight 2 UPA and sonia.

 
At 8:31 AM, Anonymous Victim of a dead democracy said...

I FULLY AGREE WITH MR VIMAL GOYAL of DELHI.



what's wrong with the nation ..! ? WHY DID WE EVER LET THE SONIA LED CONGRESS GOVERNMENT COME TO POWER !! ...


NEXT TIME PPL !! GODDAMN VOTE !! PLEASE VOTE !! and ...


dont let these retards come to power ... EVER ..

NEVER EVER AGAIN !!







DOWN WITH UPA !!!!

LET THE LAND OF GANDHI SEE THE LIGHT OF FREEDOM AGAIN !!


Someone please get to work.. down with the UPA !!


.. i CAN VOTE now .. and I VOW NEVER VOTE FOR THE CONGRESS/UPA and let them come to power .. NEVER!!


i repeat ... NEVER !

 
At 8:54 AM, Blogger chinmay said...

will someone please tell me how 2 deal with police permission for rallies ? ? ? our rally 2day in pune was silent and controlled bcause we did not hav official police permission.

 
At 9:02 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

These good for nothinf TV wallahs are conducting poll on a constitutionally invalid ammendment.. What brains does it take to conduct a poll....why don't they take a poll on how many prople believe in their facts and figures...total time pass characters

 
At 9:23 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

i think we should also ask for cheaper education loans ,which can be paid over a period of 25 -30 yrs along the lines it is in USA.

 
At 9:43 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

EXCELLENT CHARTER.

DO NOT RELENT

GOVT. WILL HAVE TO PAY FROR ALL THIS.

RESERVATIONS WILL NOT BE TOLERATED.

BEST OF LUCK

DO NOT CALL OF HUNGER STRIKE.

WE ALL PLAN TO JOIN IT SOON

 
At 9:45 AM, Blogger Aarakshan said...

Hunger strike should be taken back...
take people into confidence.. Professors, Students, Parents, Labourers, Business Men... Organise the Prabhat Pheris ... We need to have daily morchas.. Once on Parliament.. next PMO, and one by one to all Ministers,,, then the leader of oppostion.. commnunists etc....

Schools.. Colleges will start in June... Schools should be boycotted... from KG (highly optimist) to Graduate everybody should be in the morcha... and this should happen everywhere from North to South .. east to west India...

Contact NRIs .. take their support..

The cancer of Reservation needs to be treated before it enters the last stage.

 
At 11:28 AM, Blogger Amitabha said...

I support Youth for Equality entirely. The government thinks that it has found a easy way out by suggesting that general category seats will be kept constant. The action is hasty and incompetant.

All institutes are already heavily loaded with students, IITs do not have adequate labs, classrooms, dorms to support a drastic 25% increase. And where will merit stand ? In a classroom where 50% of the students are sitting because of affirmative action, how will a professor balance teaching the meritous with those who need extra attention.

Its time the government thinks about what it really needs to do. Invest more in rural education. Improve quality of state schools. Encourage private investment in education. Why does the government have to present lot of obstacles when entreprenuers want to open world class institutes in India.

The demand for an independent panel to review the needs of affirmative action is totally justified.

 
At 3:21 PM, Anonymous Mahendra verma said...

Very well thought of proposals..
I fully support this.

Very brave fight!
Let's hope more join in...

 
At 6:55 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

Dear Fellow Medical Collegues,
I really appreciate your hard work and sincere efforts for equality.
People like you are needed for the country to survive and progress.
Dont let the mission stop and dont yield to the pressure tactics by
the administration. India needs freedom from reservations to succeed
and progress.We stand with you in this job.
--
Praveen Seshabhattar,MD,MHA

 
At 10:50 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

The Charter is a very well written document.We will not relent till all our demands are met.

 
At 10:50 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

One of the good things British did for India (knowingly or unknowingly) was to rid many parts of India, of the cast divide which was deeply rooted in the society. People started believing of the possibility of them as equals. Now after having lived in the independent India for more than 50 years, some among us want to go back to the old system. They want to change the equality that exists in few places that matters, to 51% Upper casts, 27% OBC’s and 22% SC’s/ST’s (think about the scenario, if in a given year, it happens that more than 90% of the students getting through merit in IIT’s are OBC’s, then will they still restrict them to 27% and tell the rest to come back next year because you have exhausted your quota).

And what happens to the self-confidence of the person. For most of us, confidence comes from the thought of knowing that we have something great because we disserved it. What happens to our moral, when we come to know that even if we work hard and get what we want, you are told “you got it because of charity” (No one believes an SC/ST person, if he tells that, he got the promotion because he worked hard). Once a person is tagged as an OBC/SC/ST, his successes and failures are also taken as granted and attributed to the tag. The last straw is when you yourself start believing that you are inferior.

Our country needs believers who believe that they have the will and hard work to do the impossible. Even at this moment, the flame of belief is hardly feeble. Lets not blow it out….

 
At 11:17 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

ANYBODY HAS ANY CONTACTS WITH

AAMIR KHAN ?
SHABANA AZMI ?
AMARTYA SEN ?
MAHESH BHATT ?
ARUNDHATI ROY ?
AZIM PREMJI ?
THE AMBANI'S ?
NARAYAN MURTHY ?
SHOBHA DE ?
SANIA MIRZA ?
LEANDER PAES?
SHUSHMITA SEN ?
AISHWARYA RAI ?
MEDHA PATKAR ?
AND OTHER FREE THINKERS LIKE THEM ???????
CANT ANYBODY CONTACT THEM TO HELP OUR CAUSE ????

 
At 11:22 PM, Blogger mineguruji said...

Whenever the issue of reservation comes up for public debate, the entire Dalit and backward community is painted as devoid of any merit without caring about the fact that a majority of them survive without reservation.

On the other hand, the debate declares the so-called upper castes as meritorious. Therefore at this juncture when the debate on reservation is rife, let us gauge merit on both sides.
The merit of upper castes can be evaluated by assessing their performance on the basis of the traditional social structure. Looking at history the Varnas-Brahman, Kshatriya and Vaishyas were assigned with particular functions.

The Brahman had the privilege of teaching, the Kshatriya of protecting all creatures and the Vaishya living by commerce.
The Dalits could ask the Brahmans if they were so meritorious why then half of the country's population is illiterate.
If the Kshatriyas were so meritorious then why could they not defend our borders? The Shaka, Huns, Tartars, Mughals, Dutch, British etc. all defeated them and subjugated us.
Similarly, if the Vaishyas were so meritorious then why is trade and commerce of India in shambles?
In the same vein, if Arjuna of Mahabharata was so meritorious then why did Dronacharya demand Eklavya's thumb.
In contemporary times, look at the low Human Develop Index (HDI). India is placed at 127 in the group of 174 countries.

In the Corruption Perception Index for the year 2004, India ranked 90 in the group of 146 countries (Transparency International India report 2004). Above all, the external debt of India is at a whopping Rs 5,11,861 crore (Economic Survey 2003-4: p.128).

If meritorious economists and administrators are managing the affairs of the country without any reservation, why are we so economically poor?
Why are farmers committing suicide as if it is rural India's ritual? Why do we have hundreds and thousands of legal cases pending at higher levels of our meritorious judiciary?
Science and technology is considered the realm of super specialty and hence kept out of the bounds of reservation in India.

In this regard, Professor Nian Chai Liu and his colleagues at the Shanghai Jio Tong University in China spent two years collating and analyzing the output of 2000 universities worldwide and published their results by ranking 500 universities.

Only three universities/ institutions from India figured in the top 500 -- The Indian Institute of Sciences at 260 and the Indian Institutes of Technology at Kharagpur and Delhi, respectively at 459 and 460.
IIT Madras, Kanpur, Mumbai and Roorkee did not figure at all and of course there is no reservation for OBCs yet at these centres for learning.

There is something intriguing in the relationship between merit, commitment and contributing to a nation as seen by reservation bashers.
Why is that career becomes more important than service to nation to many IITians and IIMians, who wait to go abroad even before they pass out?
Let us look at the merit of the doctors working in the most prestigious hospitals of the country.
If the Indian doctors and medical specialists are so meritorious than why is that most of the VVIPs run away to foreign countries at the simplest of illnesses.

Even the former Prime Minister Atal Bihari Vajpayee, an ardent supporter of Swadeshi had to call an NRI orthopedic surgeon for his knee operation.

Further, is it not logical to evaluate the merit of the professionals passing out from the various private universities, engineering, medical and management colleges where a seat can be bought for a few lakh rupees?
There is no reservation in sports even then a nation of over a billion has not been able to produce a single individual gold medalist in Olympics.

Similarly is it really a case of meritocracy that all the progenies of film stars are given a chance to act and sing in the film industry even though they do not have any experience?

Are these cases of merit or pedigree reservation? The answer is self-evident, as most of them have been one-film wonders.

But the fact remains that most of them could reach there just because of their pedigree.

A fact often neglected. We can asses the merit of the private sector by the contribution it makes to the world export market; it is just a trickle, just 0.7%. But still, it beats my imagination why the same private sector is vehemently opposed to reservation, has been demanding a level playing field for itself with the onset of the process of liberalization.

How can even then the private sector boast of its efficiency and merit? If the Indian industries are so meritocratic, why is it that they have not produced a single brand or item which can be internationally prescribed or has become an international commodity?

What right do industrialists of today have to call themselves meritorious when most of the owners of established business houses have inherited their business from their parents?

None of the top industrialists is a first generation industrialist.
They might have expanded the business but they could do so because they belong to a certain pedigree only. According to the Ministry of Company Affairs (MCA), 122 vanishing Companies have run away with Rs 838 crore of public money.
That is why a number of social scientists have argued that the rewards in the educational and economic system are not based on merit.
The educational and occupational attainments are related to family background and a number of circumstantial parameters rather than talent and ability.
That is why people with the same educational qualification do not get the same type of jobs and those in the same jobs do not get equal remuneration.

 
At 11:28 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

The Congress-led government is turning India into a dictatorship. Peaceful protests are of no use. Wherever they see fit, they twist and change laws or even the constitution to suit their power politics. We are a democracy, god damn it! Stop dictating us by making horrible policies.

I totally support this. It is not like increasing the prices of bananas by 1 rupee, such a bill needs expert evaluation, u just can't do it like this!!!

 
At 11:50 PM, Blogger real.aam.aadmi said...

THE POINTS ARE VERY GOOD.
I WILL ALSO LIKE TO CHALLANGE THE PARLIAMENT TO PASS A BILL STATING THAT ALL M.P"S WILL GET TREATEMENT FROM RESERVED CLASS DOCTORS OF GOVT. HOSPITALS. THE GOVT. SHOULD NOT PAY FOR THEIR TREATEMENT FROM FOREIGN COUNTRIES.
Y SHOULD ONLY THE AAM AADMI SUFFER.

 
At 11:52 PM, Blogger real.aam.aadmi said...

RESEVATIONS SHOULD BE ONLY FOR THE ECONOMICALLY POOR. THE POLITICIANS KNOW THAT THE POOR ARE THEIR VOTE BANK AND WILL BE TILL THEY ARE UNEDUCATED. THE PEOPLE WHO HAVE SUFFERED FROM MEDICAL NEGLIGIENCE DUE TO FALLING STANDARDS BECUZ OF THIS RESERVATION POLICY SHOULD COME FORWARD TOO.

 
At 12:06 AM, Blogger mineguruji said...

Dear
doctors please be flexible and little kind as govt has agreed to your demands and general seats are not being touched.

Please dont stretch the merit debate too far or else the it would be very difficult to put back the genie in the bottle, once unleashed.
The govt is setting new colleges and make more recruitments and even then you dont agree then you are calling for an equal response from the opposite side.
They may be unequal in resources but not in willpower and given a chance would fight to the finish as you are calling for.
Dont fall in the Vietnam trap goaded by the glamour and style of the elite media.

 
At 12:11 AM, Blogger real.aam.aadmi said...

hi mine guruji
god forbid this but ans my q
will u take ur relative in critical state to a qouta doc

 
At 12:16 AM, Blogger mineguruji said...

India's problem is not poverty but caste system

Poor Brahmins: All the upper caste poor solidly stand behind their rich jatwalas. When the Dalits are boycotted in Punjab why no other "poor" and landless Jat comes out in solidarity? A poor Jat is also a labourer like the Dalit. But why he is not showing his "class" solidarity with his poor Dalit colleague? A poor Brahmin or other upper caste man never prevents an upper caste trying to rape a Dalit woman. Nor does he prevent a Dalit woman being paraded naked in the village. We have no instance of any "poor Brahmin" or upper caste "poor" subjected to any atrocity in Punjab villages.

Naked woman: During elections, Brahmins and other upper caste "poor" do not sell their votes. Neither are they blocked from voting. No poor upper caste woman throughout India is made naked and ordered to dance in village streets in the presence of her father, mother, sons, daughters and other relatives. This great credit is reserved only for the Dalit woman. Is there any case of burning the houses of upper caste poor? It is the upper caste poor who are employed to burn the houses of Dalits. Dalits all over India are prohibited from taking water from common well and taps.

In coastal Andhra cyclone in which thousands died, only the Dalit bodies were not touched. Mother Teresa's Sisters came to do the job. Even in Western countries upper caste people have their separate temples, gurdwaras to which Dalits are not allowed. Such is the Hindu hatred of Dalits.

Poverty no problem: In "Hindu India" poverty is not a problem. It does not create any hate. It is caste which creates hate not poverty. From birth to death Dalits are hated. Even India's richest Dalit —Jagjivan Ram —was not allowed to be buried in Delhi.

Upper caste poor get equal status in all socio-religious issues. But the Dalit, even if he is an IAS, IPS official, is a third class person. A rich Dalit is also hated for his wealth, health and official status. He is badly abused using his caste name. Dirtiest words are used to hate a Dalit even if he is rich.

Poverty is no problem in India. No poor Brahmin has revolted against a rich Brahmin. In a Brahmin institution, its owner, always employs poor Brahmins, his own jatwalas, to see that the employees do not revolt. There is no trade union of poor Brahmins against the rich Brahmin employer.

Class solidarity: There is nothing like class solidarity of the poor. In Bombay textile mills, upper caste mill workers went on strike against their own Dalit colleagues employed in the weaving section.

A "class" is temporary but "caste" is permanent. There is no promotion or demotion in a caste society.

Poverty is not permanent. It can change any time as many Dalit-Backwards have become rich in the last 30 years.

But caste is permanent. It never changes. A born Dalit dies as Dalit even if he becomes rich. In every village of Punjab Dalits have their separate burials. Caste fixes your place — not poverty.

In "Hindu India" poverty yardstick makes no sense.

 
At 12:21 AM, Blogger real.aam.aadmi said...

minegurujui please ans my q
in the name of socila upliftment should license to kill be given

y does a person need reservation for PG even after MBBS

do u understand that they even make critical mistakes.

would u like to be treated by DR laxmi SR medicine DDU Hospital, delhi.
check her out. she has been uplifted by these govt policies. ask abt her.

 
At 1:09 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

QUESTION TO MINE GURUJI

Do you feel the pain when a woman is raped ?
or do you feel pain when a dalit woman is raped by UC or any other criteria ?

If you say that CASTE is permanent and CLASS is temporary, then why stall Women's bill in the name of UC women , sc /st/ OBC women . Isn't 'AURAT jaat' a single caste.

And what is the caste of a child born to parents who married inter-caste.

And to counter your hard hitting questions pray tell me, WHAT Is the caste of the child who is born to that unforunate mother who is raped ..as stated by you.??

 
At 1:46 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

Hi,

I am not sure, but I heard that the seats in Parliament are also reserved based upon caste. They say that it was proposed that after every election the seats to be reserved for next elections would be decided by lottery system. Thus ensuring that no seat would be reserved forever.

However successive govt's decided to freeze the setup. So no changes were made after the first selection.

I think we need to fight against this.

 
At 2:56 AM, Anonymous astha said...

hey frnds, i wud suggest u to call off d hunger strike as it weakens d strong shoulders who hav to carry 4ward dis strike or u can go on relay hunger strike to make it effective on 1 hand n less fatal on d other. also try n arrange rallies in 4 different zones of delhi 4 max participation as its not possible 4 majority of d ppl 2 cum 2 aiims or 2 any other place coz of d distance. 4 d arrangement of rallies in diferent zones i.e.east, west, north, south i will take d responsibility of d funds 4 d loudspeakers. my id is as_glam@yahoo.co.in

 
At 3:33 AM, Anonymous Murali said...

Dear mineguruji,

What is your point?

For us merit means exact dictionary meaning. It does not differentiate between Brahmin or a dalit.

It just means the capability & willingness to excel. And the chance to excel should be given to all uniformly and at a level playing field.

If currently Indian private sector is doing good, it is becuase it is open to competition. Do not yet compare them with the best in the world, they have been strangled by the quota system for last 30-40 years. They are just spreading thier wings.

Let every one compete freely and fairly then you see how the society will flourish.

Lastely, let us not commit a crime to compensate for a crime that happened decades back, it will help no one.

Why does one need reservation in IIT/AIIMS, is it to earn a degree and earn quick buck for themselves? What is the intention?

I will support your cause if you say: Let the reserved candidates go back and help out the backward and needy people after thier higher education. Other wise your arguments sounds very hollow and driven by greed.

In fact thinking more about it, will a OBC who needs a open heart surgery be willing to take the cut if you tell him his surgeon belongs to his cast and was a 'reserved' candidate? OR rather will he be willing to go to doctor from his cast but is the best and most capable doctor?

 
At 5:24 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

Doctors who practice should be made to display their category - Paid or Reserved or Merit based - in prominent places in their place of practice. Paid seats are as unhealthy as reservations, but no one talks about it!! Lying about it should be punished as harshly as displaying a fake degree.

Also there should be a law in the parliament that any treatment of our leaders should be in India and in Govt. Hospitals like AIIMS. We should make them pass the law.

If some one gets treated abroad at his expense after this, it will be a good source for tax authorities to raid the person.

 
At 7:07 AM, Anonymous DR PRASAD said...

Two points to be considered-1.No population basis is used for distibution of percentage of seats.2.Time given for permanant solution or affermative action is to be decreased upto 6 months.

 
At 7:10 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

we, at SMS MEDICAL COLLEGE, JAIPUR, are organizing a big major rally tomorro morning at 8.30 am. everybody is invited to support us, support urself and support for the cause.

 
At 7:14 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

i believe somebody amongst us should come and make a political party of intellectuals and stand against these power thirsty cunning politicians. we are there to support you. only then can there be upliftment of the society but the problem is that nobody wants to take this headache. we want to become doctors , engineers but nobody wants to enter this dirty sea of politicians.

 
At 9:33 AM, Blogger subhashdua said...

Members of yfe
GREETINGS
Iam here to express my pledge and solidarity for the anti reservation movement because I sincerely believe from the core of my heart that time has come when no one should be allowed to go free with a murder, in this case the MERIT. The time has come when hard Qs should be asked why there are no roads,no eletricity,no potable water. Why after 60 yrs of independence the govt. has not been able to provide these basic necessities? Why the buildings crumble after fifteen to twenty years when they are supposed to last for 100 - 200 years? Why the murderers of Jessica Lall go scot-free? The time has come when everyone involved in the cover up should be exposed and punished.
Our thick skinned, shameless politicians have not learnt their lessons from Mandal times or are they deliberately pushing this country into chaos. These politicians knew that reservation will evoke a painful cry from the nation, they knew that people will suffer, they knew that people will die and still they went ahead with reservations. The height of shameful disgrace is that two most learned individuals are at the helm of affairs of the country and they are keeping their mouth shut. The 'devi' of sacrifice is ready to sacrifice the youth of the nation for a few votes.
Indian politicians have no stakes in making indian institutions world class, rather they have vested interests in keeping them average and struggling. They have all the money in the world to send their children and grand children to best institutes in the world and if indian institutions become world class, who will pamper their children when they come back and do not join politics.

60 years of reservation has produced thousands of MLAs and MPs. What have these people done for their community except for filling their coffers? I belong to a reserved constituency and happen to know 4 MLAs bone deep. I can testify that none of their community members have directly benefitted from them. They have the same economic status and have the same pass time as 60 years ago. The MLAs and MPs win their elections on the plank of social service but for the past 60 years, they have failed to bring any social reform or change in the community.
I believe the time has come when all reservations should be stopped and these 'social servants' should be asked to go back to their communities and devise ways to uplift them. The fact of the matter is that the country does not need politicians but social reformers who can restructure their communities.

By virtue of irrational reservation the powerful, effluent group has been produced within the scheduled tribes and the scheduled tribes. Their children have access to the best education in the world, they have all the money in their pockets to buy their children any facility they want and these are the people who corner all benefits and average and lowly sc/ st is left high and dry.
I think this is the moment of do or die, as once this reservation is implemented no one on this earth will have courage to phase it out.
Isuggest that you keep the photographs of all the polititions who matter in this country eg APJ a. kalam, Manmoohan Singh, Arjun Singh, Lalu, Paswan etc. in one corner of the Pandal and everyone should light a candle morning and evening and pray to almighty to bestow wisdom on these creatures so that they should start thinking about the country and not the cast. Similarly in another corner keep the photographs of men of eminence who have really made this country progress eg. Azim Premji, Ambanies, TATA, Birlas etc and remind them that its they who have realy made this country progress [ THIS COUNTRY HAS PROGRESSED NOT BECAUSE OF GOVT. BUT INSPITE OF GOVT. and these gentlemen will testify it,] Request them not to let this country down. Save it from the ruiins. This country has given you so much so please, please save it.
Dr subhash Dua, sea_view%myway.com

 
At 11:38 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

"Honourable" Prime Minister, did someone say? Is there any honour in leaving a field of education and becoming a politician?
I think this entire goddamned quota thing is only going to increase class division. Remember, once implemented through political channels, the people who will depend this stupid quota system attempt to go to the top, will THRASHED down, DOUBLE HARD!

 
At 11:43 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

Recently read a survey by NDTV, which states 63% of Indians are in support of quota system? Is NDTV, or the Indians, turned out to be jackasses to publish such a false report, and believe such a false report?

 
At 12:34 PM, Anonymous Vivek Jois said...

While i appreciate da hunger strike and the efforts you are taking i believe we need more tv and news paper space.pls collect money for that so you can advertise both on tv (preferably with any celeb)and in da papers so that this issue will haunt every politician everyday and every hour.pls open an account.These people should be kept under very high pressure n their lives must be made miserable.only then will they learn.

 
At 1:37 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

Hi,
We are a US IT Company and have decided not to pick any talent from india under quota catagory. I would also request all employers not to recuit people from quota. Unfortunately india is played with quota. Unfortunately we can't name it but in our management we have decided only to get the general catogry students. We are also circulating this with other US/UK companies in forum to follow.

 
At 1:44 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

It is said that hit the iron when it is hot. This quota is nothing but politics. So why do we don't use the same against goverment. In place of shouting hai, hai let's start putting posters, etc against congress, left front and BJP. Let's start calling people not to VOTE then in next election. UP is due for election soon. Let's join hand and stand up against congress & left. educate people including OBC, SC, ST how they are used for VOTES. I WILL NOT VOTE FOR CONGRESS AND LEFT ANY MORE.
DON"T VOTE CONGRESS AND LEFT.
WHO DIVIDED INDIA?? FIRST JINNA, THEN V.P. SINGH AND NOW ARJUN SINGH. THE COMMAN LINK ALL ARE FROM COMGRESS.

 
At 1:53 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

We are South African based company and have decided to hire people only from merit catagory. Earlier we hire from all catagory and now only from GENERAL.

 
At 2:36 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

P:ease , to all those who are expressing their ire against quota students, some postings are their from US and South Africa in this regard.

I'll request you to see the point that it is not General students V/s quota students.

It is about Meritocracy V/s Sectarianism..

By not taking quota students are you not falling prey to the same disease ??

Pl. accept merit irrespective of the nomenclatures on the card.

if you have any doubts in this regard ,feel free to post . Looking forward

 
At 11:26 PM, Blogger Abhishek said...

this is great. a clear, concise nd a very objective charter of demands. i suggest u organise mass campaigns all over the country nd interact with SCHOOL STUDENTS. interact on a one on one basis nd explain 2 them that it is their future which is going 2 b the most affected. i m sure that with their help our cause would b further propogated.

 
At 1:25 AM, Blogger kadampa said...

Dear Friends,
I know that just because I am from the general category and from parents who are not very well off I face a FOUR FOLD DISCRIMINATION
1. I have to compete for very limited seats in a general category
2. Many of the others studied in much better private public schools with much more exposure and attention by teachers
3. Many others had parents who could afford private tuitions and expensive coaching
4.Many others with me in school who were very dumb or wastrels or spoilt rich kids anyways are already in medical school just because their parents could afford the capitation fees.

Now that really f*@k's up the merit scenario for those in my situation and believe me: no one is listening....
IS THERE ANY ONE OUT THERE???.........

 
At 1:28 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

Hey guys I think we should leave the stinking buggers like the congress and the BJP out of this scenario..they are both hand in glove into this. let us not fool ourselves into believing that the BJP "leadership" will come out in support of this agitation.
There is no difference between the BJP or the Congress

 
At 1:38 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

Myself RAJESH from Nagpur.
MINEGURUJI IS DRAGGING THIS ISSUE IN DIFFERENT DIRECTION.
THE TALENT, INTELLIGENCE AND BRILLIANCY IS DISTRIBUTED EQUALLY IN THE STUDENTS OF ALL CASTS, CREEDS,AND EVEN IN RELIGIONS IRRESPECTIVE OF GEOGRAPHICAL BARRIERS. SO THERE IS NO QUESTION OF RESERVATION.
BUT IN INDIAN CONTEXT,SOME STRATA OF SOCIETY HAS BEEN WEEK ECONOMICALLY SINCE YEARS AND FOR THESE,DR.AMBEDKAR INTRODUCED QUOTA 60 YRS AGO.
ENOUGH TIME HAS BEEN GIVEN FOR,NO SIGNIFICANT RESULTS ARE SEEN. CURRENTLY THE ISSUE IS PURELY POLITICALLY MOTIVATED,POPULIST
AND TO ATTRACT VOTE BANK.
IN "TIMES OF INDIA" OF FEW DAYS AGO, MR.BHALCHANDRA MUNGEKAR[MEMBER OF UGC] GAVE SOME STATISTICAL DATA.
SCHOOL DROPOUT RATE OF CHILDREN OF 1.GENERAL CATEGORY [CLASS IV TO VIII] IS 23%.....THAT FOR OBC IS 32%.....FOR SC,IT IS46% ......AND THE SAME FOR ST IS 52%.
THIS MEANS, ITS IMPORTANT FOR THEM TO PROVIDE BASIC EDUCATION AND THEN THINK OF HIGHER EDUCATION.
REGARDING STUDENTDS WHO CANT AFFORD COACHING FOR IIT'S AND IIM'S..OPEN SPECIAL COACHING CLASSES FOR ENTRANCE TEST OF THESE REPUTED INSTITUTE.

IN CONCLUSION,RESESRVATION DOESNOT PRODUCE HEALHTY COMPETITION AND THIS WIDENS THE GAP BETWEEN STUDENTS OF VARIOUS "SO CALLED" CATEGORIES.

WE WANT COMLETE ROLLBACK OF RESERVATION.
DEPTT.OFPHARMACY,NAGPUR.

 
At 2:26 AM, Blogger kadampa said...

HI someone posted for us to make a political party of like minded people who are against all forms of discriminations: economic, political and social.
If you are really serious then do write to me.
http://inqalaab.blogspot.com/

 
At 2:31 AM, Blogger kadampa said...

We must demand and unite in our fight to abolish of all forms of discrimination and reservations:

ABOLISH ALL FEES FOR EDUCATION AND ABOLISH CAPITATION FEE/PRIVATE EDUCATION: (Germany has free education for all)
Good Quality Education must be a social need and FREE which has to be fulfilled by the state. After all we do pay taxes to the government to provide us quality services.
It is when, we the middle class chose to opt out of government schools that education suffered. If there were ONLY government schools we ALL (irrespective of castes) would have united much earlier and could have really kicked ass and ensured good education for all. The same happened with water, electricity, transport, health services etc.
We let the government take us for a long long ride - we did not fight... instead we chose an easy way out...today we all have aquaguards, generators, invertors, personal cars etc. and the government is sitting on its fat arse doing nothing.NOTHING. Forget higher education...Why cant the government supply clean drinking water even after 55 years of independence???
Why must we buy aquaguards while the poor ( irrespective of their caste) continue to suffer???
Why should we pay taxes and then have to pay again and again for services which are useless, while an idiot with cash becomes a doctor simply by buying his way through into private medical colleges??? WHY??
kadampa

 
At 2:46 AM, Blogger kadampa said...

Dear Murali,
If you seriously believe that past ills should be forgotten to build a better future then we all (especially those of us who are from the upper castes) must pledge to forego all the heriditary advantages and priviledges we have inherited because of our priviledged position in society such as Land, Property, Social standing.
If we only want that the lower castes must forego their loss and pain suffered for thousands of years, and nothing should pinch or prick us, then we are behaving as status quoists.
The correct postion could be to resist and fight against all forms of discriminations of land, caste based (upper or lower) property, economic , social, political, gender, color; it is only the that we can start talking of "equality".

 
At 3:00 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

Why must people only remember that we the people of India have been royally given the stick on our behinds by the government for all these years only when it pinches us. This shows a completly self absorbed selfish and myopic attitude towards life in general.
No one spoke out against capitation fee colleges in terms of merit.
No one spoke out about how the government has not been looking after the lower castes and the poor in India till before this.
Suddenly these very same people are now becoming more holy than Bhagat Singh and Chandershekhar Azad and are suddenly the conscience keepers of not only merit in this country but also deciding on how and what should government policy be towards reservations and affirmative action.
No one speaks for a level playig field where money will not be the determining factor.

 
At 3:11 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

Where were these same doctors when

User Fees were hiked in AIIMs. These user fees would have forced poor patients to pay upto Rs.15000 for emergency procedures such as endoscopic surgery?? Only a small section of doctors fought and resisted this fee hike and these same doctors are not with this agitation anyway.

Where were these same doctors at AIIMs when their collegue from Neuro committed suicide?

Where are these same doctors when the profs screw them during viva's and grade students according to personal whims and fancies?

Where were these same doctors and students for all these years when the government has hacked the health budget to less than 4% but is busy building atom bombs, flyovers and parks??

Where were these students and doctors when others were already hoarse from their shouting, "that the affirmative actions taken by the government so far have largely not benefitted the rural poor and lower castes"

Its ok for you all to fight for your selfish myopic needs, just dont crouch it in a hypocritical language of humanist and social ideals.

 
At 3:40 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

Someone was saying that the top guys of YFE is loaded with the RSS??
I mean really is this Dr. Ajay Jain of "People's Action" a Khaki Kaccha Wal???
I know these types...remember Rang De Basanti- man I dont want any trucking with these saffron types..

 
At 4:00 AM, Blogger kadampa said...

Rajesh,
please stop shouting

 
At 4:36 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

WHY DO THEY WANT TO OPEN A BANK ACOUNT IN YFE'S NAME??

 
At 7:13 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

hi friends, anti reservation rally today at jaipur was a huge success with more than 5000 people including school students, lawyers, general public, medical colleges from ajmer n bikaner and medicos including consultants. it was a peaceful march. hope positive results come out of this.
somebody asked whether i was serious about political party , i really am.

 
At 9:02 AM, Anonymous Sourav said...

POWER OF PEN AND WORDS....
Dear Friends

It has been 10 days since the students and other professionals against reservation are fighting for the just cause, in Delhi and many other parts of the country. Friends we are fortunate to have got a chance in involving for a true cause of the nation. This will surely lead to a general awareness among public and cunning politicians like Arjun Singh will not think of choosing politics as carrier any more. Let us continue this struggle with ever increasing zeal and bringing more and more public into it and protect this nation from falling into the greedy hands of select few politicians. Here are few lines from me that may make many others join this protest.

(Convert it to hindi please)
Wo Laye Then Tufan Se Kisti Nikal Ke
Aur Kaha tha hamen, ise rakhna sambhalke
Yaad hai hame wo junun wo lakho kurbani
Des Ke Liye Jo Kam Aaye, Wahi Hai Jawani
Har Garib Ko Ham Sikcha ka Haq Dilayenge
Lakh Kare Kosis Wo Hame Jati Pe Nahi Bant Payenge

Yes we remember what sacrifices were made by those who gave independence to us and we will not let our country be divided by politicians like Arjun Singh. This is written in English. If any one of you can convert it into Hindi and also pass it to those who are pro reservation groups and make them remember that it’s a nations that was brought out of great storms and make them feel that they should also come and fight for economic condition based help/reservation, it can work well. So please pass this.
The pen is mighty than sword

 
At 9:56 AM, Blogger max said...

I express my admiration & support for your agitation.

Few Thoughts:
Regarding charter of demands, I am a bit sceptical regarding the formation of some committee. Instead I trust any of you people more to come up with some ideas as we are the ones who are in the knowledge of the actual position and we are the ones going to shape the future of our country.

Many "Leaders" in the government have indicated that "All sections of the society will be looked after". Also the govt has indicated its willingness to provide the funds to match the pronuncements. I suggest the following steps/ideas to be put forward to the government which does indeed take care of all sections.

1. Primary Education should be made a fundamental right of every Indian.
2. Upto 10+2 level the government must make arrangements to provide monetary scholarship/additional mentorship to 50 % of students enrolled & coming from economically weaker sections.
3. Caste Based Reservations MUST be abolished.
4. In Undergraduate Level, 25 % of the seats to be marked for those coming from economically weaker sections of the society and the government will provide full monetary scholarship for tuition and books. For 25 % of the seats at Undergraduate level the government will make provision for providing interest-free loans repayable in 10/15 years. This way the govt will really help 50 % of the student community.
5. There should be ABSOLUTELY NO quota at Post-Graduate Level. Instead the Govt will make provision to provide interest-free loan for 50% of the seats at PG Level.

The Fight has entered a critical phase. The colleges/schools will open shortly. I suggest we brace ourselves for some tough times and spread the agitation to all the colleges taking inspiration from the same tools the founding fathers of our nation used against the British Rule viz "NON CO-OPERATION MOVEMENT" used against similar policies of that day viz "DIVIDE AND RULE". Any let up will defeat the purpose of our agitation and the support the people of our country have given us.

 
At 10:19 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

'Youth for Equality' ???????

Do you guys also call for equality and justice when your Government is marginalizing your poor?

How can you be so fake? You call it equlity when it's nothing but self-interest.

All you're interested in is protecting your little high-caste middle-class slice of the pie. India will never prosper as long as long as it's full of selfish people like you.

 
At 11:28 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

how dare u say like that - self interest blah blah. we dont mind the efficient people competing at a same level n getting jobs. if they have it in them , come n have it. there is no stopping them. i think u are among one of them only, who want the easy way out. when cant fight, u want to get that in ur bag on the basis of ur caste. it sucks. shame on u.

 
At 12:20 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

what is the need of reservations??? nobody is stopping the sc/st/obc ,they are free to study,learn& compete. then why do they need reservations??can't they compete with us.we are also like them,then why they want an easy way.Just BAN ANY TYPE OF RESERVATION.Let the deserving candidates take admission,& not the fools.

 
At 6:34 AM, Blogger Nishant Kumar said...

I support all your activities, see my blog: http://o3.indiatimes.com/indiareserved

We need to work in planned way, as reservation will never be abolished by the will of the ruling party only. As it is their bread and butter and every party supports it in their agenda for the game of votes and politics.

We need to target that issue which will disintegrate the ruling party Congress from its other allies and other parties. Only then other politicians from different parties will come forward to support our cause. It can be said that Congress has failed in implementing the reservation, when after so many years of providing reservation, still poor people are in need of reservation. Reservation is just the eyewash, and actually Congress wants to attract votes from backward classes and playing dirty politics. We need to attach many more supporting issues to this reservation issue that would show the failure of congress, so Congress party is BAD. If this will be motto, then focus will come on the credibility of the party, and eventually the party will try to makeover its stand on Reservation.

 
At 7:35 AM, Anonymous SEO IDEAS said...

I am for reservation but with certain conditions....

Unconditional reservation is wrong and should not be supported at all.

The sole criteria should bebased on economical conditions and not caste based.

 
At 8:47 PM, Anonymous dr asit khanna said...

biba please also contact mamc yfe chiefs ,they are planning to meet a lawyer who has fought 3-4 cases against reservation. i am trying to get Mr Vijayan to meet with them oo, so we can have alegal cell kind of thing

 
At 9:48 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

Dear friend ,
Do not make the mistake of inoring my suggestion

Ask a commission for Economically Weaker Section .

Atal

 
At 9:03 PM, Anonymous manish bharadwaj said...

IIT's call to all engineer and coorperate community

Hello guys,
Salute to all who are not desperated even after govt's declaration of reservation bill's implementation time.

Now its to be informed to you all that IIT Delhi students opened a help desk to contact at AIIMS ( Equality Square Park) for calling all engineers of India at a common plateform.

As you guys have seen earlier that 300 odds medicos in delhi made the govt's night sleepless ... addition of 5.76 lac engineers will definitely change the whole scenario...
and dictatorship of govt will have to pay its cost.

So its a humble request to all engineers and to coorperate sector to come and join the movement to be honest to society, to nation and to urself.

WHO DIES IF NATION LIVES, WHO LIVES IF NATION DIES

manish

 
At 11:47 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

Nothing doing only we will die and nothing will happen. If at all some thing is to happen demolish all the houses of those leaders burn their cars take one bottle blood from each and throw on near the president's house follow Netaji,s principle MAROO YA MARJAO

Anirudha Deb Assam

 
At 8:06 PM, Blogger Suresh Gupta said...

I fully support your charter of demands (COD). In fact is it the COD of every Indian who loves his or her country and wants to see it as a world power.

With your permission, I am posting this cOD on my blog, Social Hustice - http://social-equality.blogspot.com/

Visit my blog. Let us make it a all-India movement.

All the best.

 
At 10:25 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

I support your cause.Anyday, standing against Government on any issue is welcome sign that democracy lives. But you have a long way to go. Be prepared for Long March.

Govt. should start colleges/ universaties with 100% SC/ST/BC/OBC faculty, if govt. feels there is no arguement in merit. We can give 100% seats to them. Linguistic minority colleges can be conducted. Why not start reserved IIT and reserved class IIM. Let us see whethe the cremy layer in SC/ST/OBC is ready to financially support the venture.

At least Maharahtra Education Baron Mr. Chagan Bhujbal can lead by adopting this strategy or his own colleges. Or adopt this in existing college at Bandra(west) Mumbai.

 
At 10:59 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

Dear Friends,

I am from bay area, california, USA and I strongly urge you guys not
to stop this strike under any kind of pressure. We are going on a walk
on June 4 out here in the bay area, after that we will hand over a
memo to the indian ambassador too.

I am encouraging all the indians out here to raise funds for you guys
so that you can carry on this protest. We know that government is
trying to lure you into breaking this strike, but please don't stop this
protest as this might be our last chance to stop and destry this
reservation beast. The whole world will come and support you soon, 'chingari
ab chingari nahin rah gayi hai, aag mein tabdeel ho chuki hai, is aag
ko aur failne do, ye is aarakshan ko jalaakar raakh kar degi...

HAUSLA BULAND RAKKHO DOSTON.
SARFAROSHI KI TAMANNA AB HAMARE DIL MEIN HAI, DEKHNA HAI JOR KITNA
BAAJUYE 'SARAKAR' MEIN HAI...AAGE BADHO...HAM TUMHARE SAATH HAIN...

jai hind
-madan

 
At 7:08 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

bring international intelletual indian like amartya sen to justify this just cause

 
At 7:24 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

we must not be settled for shortterm gain like increase in seat. our goalpost should not be shifted.we must go to the logical conclusion once and for all.any recomendation byany expert committee will again be a blunder if it doesnot cotain the following proposal

1 entire reservation system should be phasing out within a definite time period

2. bill should contain provision that after prescribed time period it should be automatically terminatad as no political party will have teeth to terminate in future.

 
At 7:35 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

UPA has another 3 years to rule.our movement should be planned for atleast 3 years.we must not sit them happily for 3 years. we should observe and rememember a day in a year as professioanl disintegration day.all profession are now going to split on casteline.so monmohan and madam should be remember as man behind professional disintegration in india.

 
At 9:30 PM, Anonymous atul kumar kulshrestha said...

dear students(youth for equality)
I am an engineer by profession & am with you guys from the very begining. I have been to AIIMS many a times with my friends & team. In my last visit i felt your movement needs to be taken out from institutes & into the streets so I started with a rally in my area that is Palam-Vihar Gurgaon it was a modrate success & is likely to be a bigger success on next sunday(04/06/06). However I have a Suggestion for your Charter of demands let's ask goverment to ensure that reservation is available to only those who need it & as a first step towards that we will make a Data-base of all those OBCs who are well off today. List incldes Ministers,MPs, MLAs, Buereaucrates etc. believe me if we can ask govt. to agree on this wind will be knocked out from the sails of all the selfish paracites(politicians) who are presently supporting these reservations.

Thanks well done & supporting you always
Atul kumar kulshrestha

 
At 10:58 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

Please continue your strike, the whole world is coming together to support you, if you call off this strike the whole moral will go down and all your efforts will go in vain...

don't worry, supreme court can not do anything...its all games that the govt. is playing with you guys to somehow break your strike...

please continue...

jai hind
-madan

 
At 6:42 AM, Anonymous Ajay Bakhshi said...

Guys, I think we should be innovative with strikes - it can cause lot of trouble to the patients. Just a suggestion:
1. Attend all emergencies
2. Attend OPD/etc at nights instead of day time - this way "stike" is observered; it does brings in visibility (which is one of the motive of a strike anyway). The patients would be with the doctors and would still complain (about the gov and not the doctors) as they would have to handle the inconvenience of going to hospitals at night.

 
At 6:11 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

forex currency trading company - Did you know that receiving lots and lots of blogger comments increases your page rank! Resulting in a more popular blogsite.

 
At 2:02 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

It is a shame on the congress party, where on one side they say there are "all religion party and they fight for equality" and on the other side by giving reservations to OBC giving birth to in-equality attitude amongst the younster.

Don't they realise by taking this stand our own country's future is destroyed.

 
At 7:02 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

Hello
Hot girls Adult only.
ENTER sex hotgirls xanax sex sexcam phentermine+online xanax+online phentermine sex hotbabe sexforadult sex sexygirlsfree sexygirls
sexfree adult hotgirlsonline freeadult sex finder sexvideo valium meridia adultsexsearch ativan xanax drugs valium phentermine+buy viagra drug store
viagra levitra cialis Check prices of these pills:tramadol pharmacy search cialis soma ambien meridia ultram tramadol carisoprodol viagra
for fun

 
At 10:24 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

Hello. Alone on Valentine's Day? Live adult chat
for fun

 
At 5:37 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

Hi. Use these helpful search engines TFO search& and try to find all you need in your area!
Enjoy

 
At 11:59 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

Hi. Use this search engine for best result: BD search Find all you need in your area!
Enjoy

 
At 11:06 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

Hi all!. Use these helpful search engines BD search & movie pages and try to find all you need in your area!
for fun

 
At 6:08 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

The Women’s Plus Size Clothing Revolution

 
At 8:08 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

Female Hair Loss: once a mystery

 
At 3:46 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

work at home job site

 
At 4:52 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

I wonder , were to find boyfriend to my sister? Joke:)
My online friends propose this link to use -TOP10 - As for me, I think life is now!!!

 
At 9:26 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

Cool blog, interesting information... Keep it UP »

 
At 7:53 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

hi people,this is a simple test
sorry sex video
ggg

 
At 10:01 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said...







timsmovies.com
pantybuns.com
dixiecuties.com
fuckk.com
hqgal.com
busstopwhores.com
hornywolf.com
longestlist.com
frenchcum.com
captainstabbin.com

 
At 5:44 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

to accompany them to accompany them A large portion that became prevalent that were in effect sexually transmitted disease may be seen as Air Force pilots has not been uncommon to accompany them patients were female; 37 percent were white absolutely free porn video Mason University, came to that conclusion after they looked at of those states modern swinging. on any foreign tours breath mints may be readily available and once again to avoid parental notification sexual behaviors for Talking About Sex to Preteens of the world moral climate in the United and a straight- was not simply

 
At 1:47 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said...









adult video news online
hot music video
free porn video clip
free hot video
free long porn video
free gay sex video
hot asian video

 
At 11:06 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said...









seehersquirt.com
searchgals.com
video de sexo duro gratis
nastyrat.com
video diarios de sexo gratis
sexy teen video clip
home made sex video voyeur

 
At 7:03 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said...





















mature



milf

 
At 8:16 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said...









bollywood gallery teen xxx
quiz teen
black exploited teen
teen thong
gallery teen
free nude teen
teen video
cash teen
hot teen
redhead teen
free nude teen
teen thumb
nude teen
babes teen
bedding teen

 
At 12:52 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said...


















 
At 9:51 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said...













itypassplus-com.blogspot.com/>realitypassplus

 
At 6:42 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said...










spot.com/>so-so-young.com

 
At 1:27 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

Do you know that in government service, a reserved category employee superceeds a general category employee after some time. The base- just being SC/ST

 
At 9:35 PM, Anonymous viagra said...

As much as viagra has rescued the people from the cruel grip of erectile dysfunction it has also proved to be a curse to many because of wrong conception and wrong interpretation of its functioning. People buy viagra with the notion of having an extra erotic night without actually having the need to. Nowadays Viagra is also easily accessible and anyone can buy viagra online. In addition viagra online is more often than not cheap viagra i.e. a discounted version. People can easily get Viagra from the online pharmacies using wrong information. But in this way they will harm no one but their own selves, so it is always handy to have a clear conception of the drug one is taking.

 
At 6:54 AM, Blogger YOUTH BLOGGER said...

THE STORY OF RESERVATION
THE RECENT HYPE BY MEDIA, ORGANIZATIONS LIKE YFE IS MISGUIDING THE YOUTH AND ARE MADE TO BELIEVE THAT CASTE BASED RESERVATION IS GREATEST THREAT TO THEM.

They are'nt made aware of actual reality about various quotas.
Instead of the thing is BASIC PRICIPLE OF RESERVATION is objectionable. Youth seems to have believed that only CASTE BASED RESERVATION is objectionable. They are'nt made aware of various aspects of reservation and even different forms of reservation. Even if they are aware, they are blinded by some people and media to make them realize that they are upper castes which are'nt benefitted by reservations instead reservation is only against them.
They are presented misfacts about reservation especially SC/ST reservation packaged in the form of stories like grass hopper and ants.
Actually this way, castiest minds of the society are convincing the youth to follow their own caste lines and integrate them. While most youth anti reservationists raise their voices out of pure jealousy based on caste lines. While the modern youth still boasts about his higher caste pride, they can't take reservation for lower castes. May be because always their caste has been a matter a pride for them and now they are loosing something because of the same.
my blog http://reservationfacts.blogspot.com/

 
At 6:13 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

actual meaning of merit is a person who ionovate new thing discover new thing it is nothing to do with % of markes u have got . we can see that in areas where reservation dont exit show poor performance such that in field of games where no indian can got a singal gold madel but in other field where reservation policy is applied gave good result showing such as in education etc. hence YFE shoud give its narrow siting besides it shoud support the reservation beacause it is necessasry for thos cast who are debar from education , human right from more than 3000 yrs .

 
At 10:44 AM, Anonymous Dr.Anjana said...

reservation was introduced to stay for a period of 10 yrs initially.sadly b coz of the vote bank politics it has stayed on for over 60 yrs!!!!!I strongly and sternly believe that reservation should be given only to the economically backward and not as per one s religion.I support any movement against caste reservations.

 
At 2:42 AM, Blogger Tee Kay said...

http://freethinking2day.blogspot.com/

Short Essays on corruption & inequality.

Comment. Subscribe. Spread the word. (:

 

Post a Comment

Links to this post:

Create a Link

<< Home